Why the New James Charles Palette is Unnecessarily Controversial

An Unpopular Opinion, in Defense of James Charles

If you’re here from James’ tweet, thanks for stopping by! Please consider subscribing to me on YouTube:

Last week, YouTuber James Charles announced his second collaboration with Morphe, featuring a smaller version of the original Morphe x James Charles palette, plus an eyes-only version of the original brush set. The fact that the launch was just a smaller reiteration of last year’s release left many fans underwhelmed and some even angry.

As you may recall, James’ first products with the brand came out around this time last year, and faced mixed reviews of both massive praise and criticism. My personal opinion: it’s an excellent palette that can deliver endless high-impact looks, both vibrant and neutral. At $39– or less, using coupons either at Ulta or Morphe– I consider it reasonably priced for the amount of shades and possibilities you get. As much as James tends to find himself in the middle of both personal and professional drama, the palette stands on its own.

The new James Charles x Morphe Mini Collection has many fans up in arms now, calling it a “blatant money grab” and “scam” because the palette contains the exact same 39 shades, but in smaller packaging that now contains a mirror. Some criticized the lack of creativity, expecting a brand new palette.

In a YouTube video revealing the new collection, James discloses that he turned down the opportunity to create a brand new palette with Morphe and explains, “I was so proud and so confident of the color scheme that we created with the original James Charles x Morphe palette— and that these colors could truly create any single look— that I felt like if I brought out a palette of new colors, I’d be scamming people. Like, going back on my word because you literally can create any look with this palette.”

And so instead of crafting a new palette, James and Morphe sat down to discuss how they could make the original product better. Reviewing feedback from those who purchased and reviewed the original palette, they took note of the most common complaints such as the size, the lack of mirror, and the price— all three drawbacks I mentioned in my own review. James himself admitted that he personally experienced how cumbersome traveling with the original palette was over the past year, as well. The new mini palette addresses all of these concerns and creates a more consumer-friendly version of the original artist-focused palette.

The mini version is almost exactly half the size of the original (see above photo for comparison), has a built-in mirror, and contains the same 39 shades and formula for only $26 full price. The collection also features a 13-piece brush kit including James’ favorite eye brushes from the original set, sold separately.

The negative attention this launch is receiving is the epitome of a damned if you do, damned if you don’t situation. James and Morphe took constructive criticism, used it to perfect an already pretty good product, and are now being dragged for it. Yes, a new palette would have been exciting, and fans who had been expecting that may find themselves disappointed… especially when this announcement comes at the same time as Jeffree Star’s new Conspiracy Palette with Shane Dawson.

However, I have a lot of respect for James standing by his original concept while admitting that it could be improved upon. This is the palette that should have come out in the first place. This is the palette I would have bought instead, had both versions been available at the same time. Yes, it’s a bummer that a “better” product is coming out after I invested in the original, but I’m personally going to try to sell my larger palette in order to buy the new one. I have only used it a handful of times because of the downsides improved in the mini version. James himself wrote in an Instagram caption and tweet, “This collection isn’t some crazy new launch that you guys HAVE to go buy— it’s for my fans and fellow artists who have supported me.” That doesn’t sound like a strictly money-making marketing plan to me *shrug*.

James is one of those public figures that will come under fire for any decision he makes, but I’m here to call BS on the outrage over this launch. It’s no different than new iPhones being released every year with only minor tweaks. I wish more beauty brands were as receptive to consumer feedback and made changes accordingly.

For those of you who skipped the original palette due to cost or the other common concerns, I highly recommend picking up the mini. This is now the ideal travel palette, and really perfects the “do-everything” angle of the original launch. The James Charles x Morphe Mini Collection is available on October 17th at Ulta Beauty.

What do you think of the new James Charles palette controversy? Do you think this release was needed, or redundant? Share your thoughts in the comments!

14 COMMENTS

  1. I literally own the first collection and is still going to get this one. Its still the same great pallet plus great size for traveling. Now i won’t have to take mine from home or can get a smaller traveling bag. My 11 year old stepdaughter just asked me for 1 yesterday and I laughed. Now I’m going to surprise her with one also! I’m happy about it

  2. I don’t get what everyone is upset about, except that everything to do with James Charles seems to come with drama. My niece wanted the original but never got it so I may buy her the smaller version as a gift.

  3. I’m getting this palette for myself – and probably a few more for stocking stuffers. Seems very reasonable for the price and there are tons of 10% off codes around. I don’t own the original because it seemed overwhelming. Also, I hate it when there’s no mirror because I do my makeup on the couch haha.

    • Totally! At Ulta Beauty you can use their coupons on Morphe as well– when I bought the original I used a $5 off $15 plus my rewards points and got it for under $30!

  4. I think this is a great idea. I don’t think that it would’ve been met with as much criticism if it wasn’t attached to Morphe. For example, if it was the BH x LITERALLY ANYONE people would all love it. Everyone is tired of Morphe + everything attached to JC is immediate drama. I don’t agree with all things JC or all things Morphe but I think this mini palette is a good idea, especially for his younger fans like my daughter who definitely don’t need that larger palette (though she has it lmao).

    • Agreed. People just love to hate sometimes, even when it’s not deserved. And it’s true!! BH Cosmetics actually did the exact same thing– they started putting out mini versions of their Zodiac palette because the originals were so huge, even though people loved the formula. Soooooooo how is this different lol!

  5. I am just in love with the fact that it’s got a mirror, that’s a huge selling point for me. I’m on a no buy for makeup, but I will once the new year comes.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here