The search for the next best eyeliner formula seems never ending. I personally prefer liquid liner for every day wear, because there are very few pencil liners that I can stand using. When I use pencil eyeliners, they need to be super soft, pigmented and long lasting. When I heard about the Essence Gel Eye Pencils, I was skeptical but intrigued.
There are six pencils in this collection, with a color for every look. They are twist up style, so no sharpener needed. Each cap indicates the color of the pencil so you can find which one you’re looking for easily.
From left to right:
- Black Blaze is a deep, pure black.
- Gunmetal is a charcoal gray with silver shimmer.
- Cocoa Bean is a chocolate brown.
- Around Midnight is a navy (that almost looks purple) with blue shimmer.
- Blue Lagoon, my favorite, is an ocean teal shade with a metallic finish.
- Urban Jungle is an emerald green with green shimmer.
Right off the bat, the gel formula glides on effortlessly with high intensity color payoff. The shades pop off the skin with full opacity; I was extremely pleased with their appearance and ease of application. They are also very soft and bendable, so you can create some killer smokey eyes with them before they set. Once they dry down, they stay put for about 6 hours without creeping around the eyelid like other soft liners do. They live up to their waterproof claim; under running water there’s no smearing or dripping, and it takes a lot of force to rub them off. On the waterline, they last up to four hours before the color starts to fade.
The one problem I had with the pencils was isolated to the shade Black Blaze. After using it for the first time and being super impressed, I put it away for about a week before picking it back up again. Trying to apply it a second time, it felt dried up and hardly any color was transferring onto my eyelids. Thinking perhaps it was just a dud in the batch, I got another one in the same shade. Unfortunately, the exact same thing happened, and it took incredible force to get the swatch you see in the photo above. Luckily, none of the other pencils dried out the way Black Blaze did, but it’s a bummer since that one would have been my most used out of the bunch for every day looks.
Overall, most of these pencils are lovely to work with and offer stand-out colors with good pigmentation, with the exception of Black Blaze. They’re only $3 and are available at Ulta. I’m still curious to see if I’m the only one who experienced problems with the one shade, so if you’ve tried these, let me know how they worked for you in the comments!
What do you look for in a pencil eyeliner?